The Courage to Challenge: A New Era for Non-Executive Directors

In the fast-evolving landscape of 2023 and 2024, leadership is facing new pressures from economic volatility to environmental challenges, technological disruption, and shifting societal expectations. In these uncertain times, we often see leaders tempted to choose the path of least resistance, prioritising popularity and short-term comfort over difficult decisions. Whether it’s economic policy, climate action, or navigating the complexities of corporate governance, there’s a growing sense that many leaders are favouring popularity over true accountability and effectiveness.

This brings to mind a critical lesson for Non-Executive Directors (NEDs). Confusing popularity with effective leadership is a dangerous path for any board member. In the high-stakes world of governance, especially in this era of transformation, courage is not just a nice-to-have trait, it’s essential.

Integrity and Courage: The Foundation of Effective NEDs

In our experience of working with boards across sectors from FTSE 100 companies to emerging startups, two qualities consistently stand out as essential for an effective NED: integrity and courage.

Integrity is, of course, foundational. Most directors we’ve encountered are genuinely committed to their organisation's values and to doing what’s right. However courage, the ability to challenge, to ask uncomfortable questions, and to stand firm even when it’s unpopular is a much rarer quality, especially in this current climate where there’s pressure to appear aligned with consensus or follow public opinion.

Ian reflects that in the extensive board reviews he’s conducted, a common issue is the lack of genuine challenge from NEDs. Directors can often focus on detailed or minor issues, like grammatical errors in board papers or ask clarification questions but avoid more critical discussions, like: why isn’t the company investing in more sustainable business practices when stakeholders are clearly expecting it? Why is the CEO pushing for aggressive expansion when the current operation is struggling to stay on track? The reluctance to engage in difficult conversations or to challenge the executive team is a major missed opportunity and, frankly, an example of NEDs not doing their job.

Embracing Discomfort for the Greater Good

The Financial Reporting Council, in its governance guidelines over a decade ago, stated clearly that being on an effective board is not always a comfortable experience. And yet, many NEDs still shy away from challenge for fear of creating tension or upsetting the balance in the boardroom. However, in 2024, discomfort is where growth happens. Discomfort is where innovation is born. Discomfort is where truly resilient companies emerge.

The truth is discomfort doesn’t need to breed division. The most effective NEDs understand that challenge and collaboration are not mutually exclusive. They know how to assert their views in a constructive way, aiming for quality debate rather than confrontation.

Smart NEDs are intentional in their approach to board meetings. If they plan to challenge on a material issue, they often take the time to connect with the responsible executive beforehand. This approach gives the executive a chance to clarify or prepare for further scrutiny, leading to a more productive discussion in the boardroom. It’s about ensuring rigorous debate, rather than catching anyone off guard or fostering defensiveness.

The Role of Constructive Challenge

Effective NEDs don’t see their role as simply approving the executive team’s decisions. Rather, they view themselves as partners in ensuring thorough debate, careful scenario planning, and robust decision-making. Their goal is to support, challenge, and ensure the board explores all the possibilities before making strategic choices.

These NEDs know that there will be moments when they must be the dissenting voice, the one who asks the tough questions, or makes the unpopular statement. For example, in today’s climate, companies are under increasing pressure to balance profitability with sustainability and social responsibility.

It’s the courageous NED who stands up and asks if short-term profits are worth sacrificing long-term corporate resilience. It’s the courageous NED who demands a closer look at technology investments to avoid being left behind in the face of digital disruption. This is courageous leadership in action. It’s about recognising that, as a NED, there will be both comfortable and uncomfortable moments in the boardroom. And that’s okay. Comfort should not be the goal. Effectiveness should be.

A concept we emphasize during our annual CEO retreats is the 'business athlete' mindset. Just like elite athletes, CEOs need to maximise the conditions needed to achieve and sustain high levels of energy. This includes:

The Courage to Lead in Uncertain Times

As we navigate the challenges of 2024 and beyond, from economic headwinds to the rapid pace of technological change, remember this: courage is more important than popularity. You must be willing to challenge, to ask difficult questions, and to stand your ground when it matters most. This doesn’t have to be in a confrontational way – indeed it is important it is done constructively and the best NEDs use a coaching style approaching each decision with integrity and a commitment to the long-term success of the organisation.

In an era where leadership can sometimes feel like a popularity contest, it’s easy to get distracted by the desire to fit in or be liked. But the most effective NEDs know that courage, not consensus, is the true measure of leadership. Popularity may win you a few moments of praise, but courageous decision-making is what drives sustainable success.

So, when you find yourself in the boardroom, faced with a difficult decision or an unpopular stance, remember this: leadership isn’t about being liked. It’s about doing what’s right. And sometimes, that means having the courage to stand alone.

The Bottom Line

In 2024, as we face unprecedented disruptions and challenges, the role of a NED is more crucial than ever. To be truly effective, we believe you must embrace courage over comfort, and focus on leading your organisation through both the easy and difficult moments. It’s not about personal popularity, it’s about helping to steer the organisation towards long-term success.

The courageous NED understands that leading with integrity and vision is not always easy, but it is always necessary.

INSIGHTS